5.6.40
Fine Wine Diary The Bailey brothers have now tasted 12082 wines in 28 years 10 months and 13 days
... search our archive of tasting notes ... read our articles on tastings and dinners

Wine Group at E. O'N.'s 23/03/2004 TNB

We started with the 1996 vintage from Moet and Veuve-Cliquot - a pair I had a month or two ago at a tasting. The V-C seemed better here (supporting those at the tasting who claimed to have had better bottles) without really seeming that special and the Moet was very odd indeed, grassy and a touch sweet.

The star of a flight of Provence whites was the Palette 2001 from Chateau Simone, herby, stylish, low-acid wine which I spotted (we were tasting blind) having had an older vintage a while ago. Their red would probably have led a small flight of Provence reds also but unfortunately (because it is a wine I have long wanted to try) it was corked. A Bandol 1993 from Vannieres was showing its age rather but Chateau Rasque showed well in both white and red - not a wine I have seen over here but well-made.

In amongst this we had also the Gran Reserva 1994 from Riscal - rather jammy and modern, and it surely will not age the way that Riscal used to in the past and I thought it a bit sad that such a famous old property has gone so commercial. I was surprised by how dry, concentrated and serious the 1994 Bin 707 from Penfolds was - it's always been a good wine of course but I have often found it a bit soft for my taste. This is probably not at peak yet and might even rate **** in time - pretty impressive.

Dow 1970 seemed a bit spirity and very mature - lovely flavours too, but not quite as I remember it. It's probably bottle variation, or of course bottler variation: I forgot to note which bottling this was. Marsala Travecchio 1920 from Florio reminded my of burnt Christmas pudding - like a Madeira without the same piercing acidity but still very enjoyable.




added to Fine Wine Diary 23/03/2004   Return to top