Fine Wine Diary The Bailey brothers have now tasted 12016 wines in 21 years 11 months and 10 days
... search our archive of tasting notes ... read our articles on tastings and dinners

A Bordeaux dinner 10/03/2005 (TNB)

No great surprises at a recent small dinner in which all the wines sang. Prejudices confirmed in order were: Josph Perrier is an under-rated Champagne house; the top white Graves are incomparably exciting wines; 1982 is a great Bordeaux vintage; Magdelaine and Canon are fine properties; there is nothing quite like Ausone. One prejudice lost a little ground - I am not a particular fan of Coutet but I must say the 89 is a very good wine.

I was very taken with the 82 Ausone, although perhaps one could imagine a larger or a firmer wine that might be even more exciting. The usual authorities seem unsure about it: Parker 90? wonders where it is going; Coats 13.5-15 says it is "by no means great"; Broadbent runs to 4-stars and it reminds him of Daphne's rice pudding. I would rate it higher than any of those but perhaps partly because I love the stylish individuality of the property's wines.


Dinner added to Fine Wine Diary 15/04/2005   Return to top