Fine Wine Diary The Bailey brothers have now tasted 12016 wines in 21 years 11 months and 10 days
... search our archive of tasting notes ... read our articles on tastings and dinners

Diary index

Recent drinking 27/04/2004 (TNB)

A few recent bottles of fizz 19/04/2004 (TNB)

Bordeaux at Oddbins 19/04/2004 (TNB)

Italian evening at Harvey Nichols 19/04/2004 (TNB)

Wine group partners' dinner 19/04/2004 (TNB)

At Kinnaird 04/04/2004 (TNB)

A recent Oddbins tasting 04/04/2004 (TNB)

At Martin's Restaurant 04/04/2004 (TNB)

In London recently 04/04/2004 (TNB)

The Diary - April 2004

Recent drinking 27/04/2004 (TNB)

  • Rully 2001 (Dureuil-Janthial) Quite bold, rich wine - could easily be a village Chassagne. Not over-ambitious - just very good drinking Burgundy. This producer has some more prestigious bottlings that I would be interested to try. **
  • Corton 1er Cru Les Vercots 1999 (Follin-Arbelet) Crushed red fruits, high-toned cranberry fruit. Nice concentration and length. I first noted this at J & B's en primeur tasting three years ago and rated it as three stars in the long run - it's there already and still improving. It will be at least a very good three stars at peak. ***
  • Chablis 1er Cru Vaillons 1989 (Michel) At first taste a bit faded, but with further attention (and perhaps some opening out) it has lovely citric fruit, mineral and not lacking concentration. Some will say this should have been drunk a year or two ago but I like it still. Top **
  • Beaucastel Rouge 1989 Pretty soft and easy-going with mushroomy/gamy notes. Very Beaucastel. I've enjoyed this more before - this time I'll stick to a top ***
  • Corton Charlemagne 1992 (Bonneau de Matray) Pleasingly mineral and fairly intense, but lacking the extra buzz you might hope for from a Grand Cru. No more than a decent effort. ***
  • Savennieres La Jalousie 2000 (Domaine du Closel) Concentrated, approachable without being simple or soft and with a lovely minerality and sense of terroir. Not really a keeping style I guess but very nice indeed. Good **
  • Cabernet Sauvignon Private Reserve Georges de Latour 1989 (Beaulieu) I last remember tasting this wine in a range of vintages in about 1986 in a tasting event at a wine store in Houston, Texas. I liked them then and I like this now - completely ready for drinking with lovely mature fruit, quite forward but one might have trouble spotting it as not Claret blind, with a nice touch of tobacco and ciogar box. Very nice drinking. Maybe even ****
  • Nottage Hill Chardonnay 2001 (Hardy) Grassy, fat and somewhat harsh. Decent No Stars in its way
  • Corse Calvi Rose 2002 (Domaine Cardi) A bit rough and lacking freshness - flat rose character. Decent No Stars
  • Chardonnay 2003 (Weinmanufaktur Krems) Clean dry fresh chablis-like - even slightly mineral. A strong *
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 27/04/2004   Return to top

A few recent bottles of fizz 19/04/2004 (TNB)

Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 19/04/2004   Return to top

Bordeaux at Oddbins 19/04/2004 (TNB)

  • Chardonnay 2000 (Mulderbosch) Pleasant melony chardonnay fruit. Fresh sherberty palate. A bargain if one likes the fairly up-front style. **
  • Les Hauts de Pontet Canet 2000 Dense fruit, quite baked on nose. Dry palate, hints of blackcurrant but too cooked to be clear. Slightly stalky and green on finish - rather highly extracted. A bit overdone. **
  • Clos Canon 2000 Creamy, camphor, in-your-face nose. Creamy on the palate too. Sexy and nice drinking. Top **
  • Connetable de Talbot 2000 Subdued but pleasant nose. Very middle-of-the-road at first taste but it follows through very strongly. **
  • Chateau Duhart Milon Rothschild 2000 Classic capsicum and privet nose. Smoky palate - gorgeous mineral finish. Very good indeed - perhaps even ***(*)
  • Lacoste Borie 2000 Cinnamon (lots) and fruitcake nose. Morello cherries - sexy style again. Top **
  • Chateau Malescot St Expury 1995 Classic blackcurrant - dry - nice sweet fruit and a strong finish. Drinking nicely. ***
  • Chateau Pontensac 1996 Varnishy shoe-polish nose. Meaty palate. Interesting old-fashioned wine. Structured. Still improving but not to the extent of another star, I feel. ***
  • Chateau Leoville Poyferre 1994 A bit of smoke on the nose (dead fireworks in the dew the morning after, someone said). Dry, tannic, the structure perhaps obscuring the length. On returning - just very good classic Claret. ***(*)
  • Rayne--Vigneau 1988 Rhubarb and cream - quite restrained - long creme brulee palate. Quite Barsac in style. Very good. ***(*)
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 19/04/2004   Return to top

Italian evening at Harvey Nichols 19/04/2004 (TNB)

  • Soave La Rocca 2001 (Pieropan) Honeysuckle nose and big but refined peachy garganega fruit. Opens out in the glass. Very fine and long. ***(*)
  • Viognier Podere di Montalupa 2000 (Ascheri) Big wine with fat Viognier fruit. A bit of oak gracefully carried. Interesting. Just ***
  • Friuli Vintage Tunina 2001 (Jermann) Ambiguous nose - hard to put a name to any component but intruiging. Dry, very precise, intense fruit. Top ***
  • Chianti Classico 2000 (La Massa) Blackberry fruit - dense for chianti. Ripe. Solid tannins - quite ambitious. Needs 4-5 years an will be rather good drinking then I suspect. Conservatively, a top **(*)
  • Monsordo Langhe Rosso 2000 (Ceretto) Blackcurrant nose (the Cabernet component of a mix of grapes dominant). Nice acidity. High-toned, good tannins. Food wine. The cocktail of grape varieties is a bit too evident currently but I expect they will meld and despite the modern style there is an authentic sense of place about it. Say a top **(*)
  • Brunello 1998 (Sesti) Tarry nose - farmyardy fruit. Gamy - quite sexy. I sense the winemaking here is OK but not quite in the class of the other wines. Will get better probably, but maybe not to the extent of more stars. ***
  • Rosso di Montalcino 2001 (Sesti) A bit rustic again, like the Brunello, but a fruity very drinkable mouthful! **
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 19/04/2004   Return to top

Wine group partners' dinner 19/04/2004 (TNB)

Brief notes, made the day after.
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 19/04/2004   Return to top

At Kinnaird 04/04/2004 (TNB)

  • Chablis Vaillons 2000 (Michel) Very pure and mineral - as often with this producers wines each glass seems more rewarding than the last. Very nice. ***
  • Champagne Brut Premier (Roederer) Mature - lovely and rich with a beautifully textured mousse. Cashew nuts. I suspect this half had been in the cellar tor a year or two. **** even
  • Soave Classico 2002 (Pieropan) Completely drinkable - very pure and while unassertive it has a lot of character if you stop and think about it. **
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 04/04/2004   Return to top

A recent Oddbins tasting 04/04/2004 (TNB)

  • Rudesheimer Berg Schlossberg Spatlese 2002 (J. Leitz) Floral peachy nose - pink grapefruit. Sweet palate seems a bit short on acidity right now - is this just young riesling's trick of seeming a bit simple? I suspect this will be at least rather good. At least *(**)
  • Rudesheimer Berg Roseneck Spatlese 2002 (J. Leitz) More slatey - sherberty and mouthwatering than the previous wine - more obvious quality at this stage. Easy **(*)
  • Chardonnay 2001 (Voyager Estate) In-your-face tinned fruit and vanilla. Very limey and oak-dominated palate. If this is your sort of thing you might want to give it **
  • Puligny Montrachet 1997 (Drouhin) Waxy, hints of marzipan. Flat but broad palate. Curious wine (I was wondering blind if it might be Rhone) but rather nice. ***
  • Beaucastel blanc 2002 Neutral nose with gamy hints. Acacia palate. This really does not seem so interesting - I hope this excellent estate aren't losing the plot. **
  • Syrah 2001 (Boekenhotskloof) Intense blackberry fruit, highly extracted, slightly bitter. I'm not at all keen on this. *
  • Chateau Fieuzal 2000 Blackcurrant and cedar with those funky/smoky Graves notes. Pretty tannic but rather good - will be fine in ten years or so - possibly even **(**)
  • Roda I 1999 Green peppercorns and solvents - curious but not unattractive nose. Stylish, creamy, new-wave wine with a bit of earthy minerality. Nice length. ***.
  • Fusion V 2001 (De Torren) Crushed mint, reasonably balanced, dry, quite meaty. Nicely structured. Good if you don't mind the mint. **(*)
  • Beaucastel rouge 2001 Burnt raisiny nose, silky fruit. Very fine but I'm not sure at this stage that this is going to be a great Beaucastel. At least ***
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 04/04/2004   Return to top

At Martin's Restaurant 04/04/2004 (TNB)

Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 04/04/2004   Return to top

In London recently 04/04/2004 (TNB)

  • Amontillado del Puerto (Lustau) Good - fine with a long finish. Easy ***
  • Brunello Riserva 1980 (Mastrojanni) Showing its age with a touch of oxidation that seems to blow off. In remarkably good condition if with a slightly rustic fruit quality. Very good drinking. I've not tried this producer's wines before that I remember but this is pretty good, even given that this was apparently a reasonably good Brunello vintage. Top ***
  • Lamothe-Guignard 1989 Rich, sweet, good botrytis but possibly a bit heavy overall. ***
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 04/04/2004   Return to top