Fine Wine Diary The Bailey brothers have now tasted 12016 wines in 21 years 11 months and 10 days
... search our archive of tasting notes ... read our articles on tastings and dinners

Diary index

Four French reds and a Californian white 30/04/2005 (RJB)

Gang of Five - Guigal Cote Rotie and others 28/04/2005 (RJB)

An Edinburgh offline 27/04/2005 (TNB)

Wine group at MM's 25/04/2005 (TNB)

A mixed four 22/04/2005 (RJB)

15/04/2005 (TNB)

Three Barossa Verticals 15/04/2005 (RJB)

Some recent things 09/04/2005 (RJB)

In Berlin 08/04/2005 (TNB)

The Diary - April 2005

Four French reds and a Californian white 30/04/2005 (RJB)

Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 06/05/2005   Return to top

Gang of Five - Guigal Cote Rotie and others 28/04/2005 (RJB)

A blind tasting, other than the fizz, which included five vintages of Cote Rotie Brune et Blonde from Guigal.
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 28/04/2005   Return to top

An Edinburgh offline 27/04/2005 (TNB)

  • Champagne Grand Cru Blancs de blancs Extra Brut NV (Selosse) Very vinous - Burgundy with bubbles, to some extent and so a bit much in some ways. I suspect it needs time to mellow - it will be interesting to see how this develops (this bottle was disgorged only last year). If all goes well ***(*)
  • Champagne Blanc de Noirs Grand Cru Vieilles Vignes NV (Egly-Ouriet) All quite refined and delicate, appley pinot fruit, autolytic flavours. Another fairly recent disgorgement after 4 years in cellars (credit the producer for an excellent back label), it just seems a bit lacking in intensity despite the obvious quality. Perhaps this will develop but for now a good ***
  • Eden Valley Riesling 2003 (Mesh) Good fruit - nice acidity. Pretty intense although it seems quite evolved for a young wine - I fear it may go down the Ozzy route of rather early flabby kerosene flavours. Top ** anyway
  • Vouvray sec 2001 (Vodanis - Huet) Curiously Sauvignon-like - quite rich. Odd balance - people were saying this is a vineyard Huet took on and then abandoned. Good wine but it doesn't seem to have the class of their major wines. A low **(*)
  • Pouilly Fuisse 2002 (Cordier) Pretty nice. Clean, rich, yet decently taught. A credit to the appelation. Bare ***
  • Rioja Reserva Especial 1947 (Palacio) A weak cork and a rather oxidised bottle - one sips for a while but then abandons it. I have had much better. Not Rated
  • Rioja Reserva 1958 (Riscal) Very light and delicate - decent but a bit attenuated. I have had better bottles. ***
  • Syrah 1998 (Richeaume) Dry, savoury, quite succulent. Pleasantly high-toned, nervy, and a bit awkward. A wine with a sense of place and hence enjoyable. ***
  • Bandol 1995 (Pradeaux) Curiously quiet, but concentration and fruit quality are all there. Maybe just in a dull phase - perhaps it would have shown better decanted and allowed a little air. ***
  • Lourens River Valley 2000 (Morgenster) Leafy, dry, decent balance. Good wine but I doubt it's going anywhere much. Pleasant, and perhaps it would reward further attention. **
  • Old Vine Grenache, Kangarilla Vineyard 1996 (Clarendon Hills) Quite baked, decent concentration - slightly hot finish. I recall having had better from this producer. **
  • Geyserville 1996 (Ridge) Refined, smooth sweet (to a controlled extent) - very drinkable. Forward fruit but with the balance to hold it - the best of the New World reds, to my palate. Top ***
  • The Armagh 1993 (Jim Barry) Huge monster - alcohol gets up my a nose and in my throat rather. I find this a bit much. Returning to it later it seemed to have mellowed quite a bit and to be a substantial wine in its way, although I find it hard to decide about it. Many will admire this, and I may too given time to consider it - I had it eight and a half years ago and was impressed. I think I'll reserve judgement for now. Not Rated
  • Marquis d'Auberjon NV A bit anonymous in some ways, but very nicely poised fairly concentrated dessert wine - from the South of France somewhere, I guess. I suspect this would repay more attention and on that basis ***
  • Recioto di Soave Le Colombare 2000 (Pieropan) Beautifully refined. Complex, elegant, long with the amazing precision so typical of the producer. Lovely. ****
  • 50 year old Tawny (Yalumba) Eccentric - very rancio - complex and interesting - I need more time with this but for now ***
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 01/05/2005   Return to top

Wine group at MM's 25/04/2005 (TNB)

Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 03/06/2005   Return to top

A mixed four 22/04/2005 (RJB)

Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 26/04/2005   Return to top

15/04/2005 (TNB)

A couple of wines from a big bash at an Edinburgh hotel. It's a good idea once in a while to remember where the baseline is.
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 08/05/2005   Return to top

Three Barossa Verticals 15/04/2005 (RJB)

Each done as a vertical - single blind
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 15/05/2005   Return to top

Some recent things 09/04/2005 (RJB)

Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 12/04/2005   Return to top

In Berlin 08/04/2005 (TNB)

Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 08/05/2005   Return to top