Fine Wine Diary The Bailey brothers have now tasted 12016 wines in 21 years 11 months and 10 days
... search our archive of tasting notes ... read our articles on tastings and dinners

Diary index

Recent Italian and Spanish wines 29/01/2003 (TNB)

Some wines from a tasting at Veritas Wines, Cambridge 27/01/2003 (RJB)

A late reported pre-Christmas dinner 20/01/2003 (RJB)

Wine Group at E.McC. 19/01/2003 (TNB)

Reds from V ∓ C 12/01/2003 (TNB)

Wine Group at E.O'N 05/01/2003 (TNB)

The Diary - January 2003

Recent Italian and Spanish wines 29/01/2003 (TNB)

  • Soave Calvarino 2001 (Pieropan) This has an admirable stony mineral purity, but as sometimes with this producer the wine is a bit understated even for my tastes. Classy though, and a touch of honeysuckle when it opens ud suggests it might merit another star in time. For now a conservative **
  • Soave Classic Superiore Monte Alto 2000 (Ca Rugate) Honeysuckle nose, pineapple fruit, bone-dry, a touch of stonyness with good concentration and a long finish. I wonder if there is a touch of oak on this - if so it is well-handled. Top stuff - this estate is clearly trying to challenge the top estates in Soave. This might even improve for a year or two. Without making much allowance for style I think it just about merits ***
  • Bucciato 2000 (Ca Rugate) Deep golden honey colour. Intense nose of peach stones and honeysuckle followed by a big palate. The limits are being pushed here but I think it carries it off. This is 100 per cent Garganega apparently but the word Soave doesn't appear on the label - I don't know why. Intriguing. ***
  • Recioto della Valpolicella Classico 1997 (Allegrini) Intense blackberry fruit, a touch of mushrooms and nuts - terribly suave as Allegrini's wines usually are. For sipping. ***
  • Palazzo Della Torre 1999 (Allegrini) This is really Valpolicella but sold as IGT because of some minor violation of the rules - not enough Thompsons Seedless in the blend, or some such. Pretty smooth with delightful cherry flavours as it opens up in the glass. Suave - almost a shade too suave perhaps but very pleasant drinking. **
  • Amarone della Valpolicella Classico 1997 (Brigaldara) I bought a couple of these after a tasting. Lots of baked plum fruit, good tannins and a long finish. The fruit is quite silky, the style fairly modern - it will be interesting to see how it ages. It lacks real terroir distinction perhaps and I suspect it will age faily well without meriting an extra star. Good wine. ***
  • Rioja Gran Reserva 1994 (Solar de Amezola) Lovey scented fruit - quite fresh but mellowed by traditional cask aging. How nice to drink something unforced. ***
  • Torro, Oro 1999 Light strawberry fruit, slides down the hatch pleasantly enough but has no real length or complexity. Decent BBQ wine. It's honest so I will give it the benefit of the doubt: *
  • Ribera del Duero Reserva 1995 (Briego) The nose is herby with overtones of game. The fruit is silky raspberries, Burgundian almost. Very good. ***
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 29/01/2003   Return to top

Some wines from a tasting at Veritas Wines, Cambridge 27/01/2003 (RJB)

Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 27/01/2003   Return to top

A late reported pre-Christmas dinner 20/01/2003 (RJB)

Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 20/01/2003   Return to top

Wine Group at E.McC. 19/01/2003 (TNB)

Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 19/01/2003   Return to top

Reds from V ∓ C 12/01/2003 (TNB)

  • La Strada Pinot Noir 1999 (Fromm) Authentic beetroot and red fruits, a bit on the jammy side but controlled. Gluggable if simple. A very good *
  • Lagrein Scuro 2000 (Franz Haas) Intense blackberry fruit - forward and fairly modern in style perhaps but very drinkable. **
  • Chiant Classico 2000 (Castello Della Paneretta) Juicy and high-toned. A nice example without being very special. I don't think this would quite keep up with the pace among the very best estates, but I may be wrong. A top *
  • Condado de Haza 1998 (Fernandez) A Temranillo from the Pesquera man, I think. One bottle marked by sulphur and another rather rustic. Different bottles open at the end seemedto vary too! The best might almost merit two stars, the worst really not good. I have my doubts about this. *
  • Merlot Riserva 1999 (De Gras) Quite cherryish - soft, pleasant. This Chilean offering is a bit dull. *
  • Burdese 1999 (Planeta) This has a raw astringant streak through some fairly classy fruit. Is that careless oak handling? This is the second time I have tasted this recently and I am not very enthusiastic - it is rather forced. **
  • Montepulciano d'Abruzzo Le Coste 1998 (Barone Cornacchia) Touch of forrest about this which adds a bit of class - and it is fine if you like your reds big. This is an honest mouthful of fruit. **
  • Rosso Conero Cumaro 1998 (Umani Ronchi) A rather more delicate take on those woodland morning flavours. Nice, balanced wine. This is a bit more to my taste. A rather good **
  • Palazzo della Torre 1999 (Allegrini) Nicely, rounded, silky - terribly attractive and drinkable. This estate does a good job generally. Pure fruit. If one is going to criticise, the overall effect can be a bit soulless ***
  • Barbera d'Alba Croere 1999 (Terre da Vino) This has a rather arresting nose - blackberries and spice. I guess this and the rich palate owes a lot to new oak but it is all nicely integrated. A bargain. ***
  • Brunello Poggio Alle Mura 2000 (Banfi) This is very young to be drinking Brunello. Structured, decent length. There's a decent core of fruit too. This is at least pretty good: **(*)
  • Barbaresco Pora 1997 (Produttori del Barbaesco) Tar and roses - pretty authentic - but guite forward. Pretty much drinking and as good as a lot of Nebbiolo at the price. Disappointing if one is thinking in terms of 97 Barbaresco, but it is not wildly expensive. **
  • Crozes Hermitage 2000 (Dumaine) Pretty much Crozes certainly. Dry raspberry fruit. Possibly a bit bland but pretty enjoyable. **
  • Nine Popes 1999 (Charles Melton) Lots of spicy cherry - the Barossa is quite good at this sort of Southern Rhone blend (better than it is at straight Shiraz, in my opinion). There's a touch of astringancy here that holds me back from 3 stars. Possibly not this estate's best vintage. Top **
  • Old Vine Zinfandel 1999 (Seghesio) Well, very Zin - a nose so deep you could dive in. Silky, long, and I think it has an old vine depth. ***
  • Amarone Il Bosco 1997 (Cesari) Old-fashioned - a faint touch of sherry and possibly even volatility. Very meaty, cooked fruits. I spent a while tasting this idiosynchratic thing and I think I rather like it. ***
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 12/01/2003   Return to top

Wine Group at E.O'N 05/01/2003 (TNB)

  • Bellavista Cuvee Brut NV (Franciacorta) Soft nutty, light, unassertive. Attractive and elegant - I would be interested to taste one of the top bottlings of what has the reputation of being one of Italy's topp fizzes. A good **
  • Pelorus 1998 More substantial but a bit duller. A bit rustic and lacking finesse. Prematurely aged too. I am not terribly impressed. *
  • Chardonnay Proprietor Grown 1996 (Beringer) A bit flabby perhaps - rich, mouthfilling, flavoury - it's a big style but reasonably controlled. **
  • Chardonnay Proprietor Grown 1997 (Beringer) Leaner - nice thick texture - attractive vegetal components. Has the edge on the 96 without quite making an extra star, I think. (I wonder if I am being just a touch mean about these two?) **
  • Chateau Capet-Guillier 1997 Leafy blackcurrant, interesting at first but maybe old-fashioned but not necessarily fine. (One of those odd St Emilion properties that one keeps discovering.) *(*)
  • Chateau Canon La Gaffeliere 1997 Warmer raspberry nose. A bit raspy on the palate - but opens up in the glass. Serious. **(*)
  • Chateau Batailly 1997 Nice blackcurrant fruit. Charming. Forward. **
  • Chateau Pichon Baron 1997 Corked. Not Rated
  • Chateau Latour 1997 Lovely sweet fruit. Stylish and pretty concentrated - round and meaty. Needs some time to be at its best. ***(*) (just)
  • Chateau Pichon - Lalande 1997 Sweet ripe fruit. A bit more forward than Latour and while pretty good it won't ever catch up, I feel. **(*)
  • Chateau Coutet 1958 Apricot. Quite dry now. Savoury. Not a lot of length perhaps but very charming. What a pleasant surprise from an unregarded vintage. Top ***
  • Chateau Sigalas Rabaud 1989 Amber and green. Sweet and nutty. Richer - tending towards flab a bit. ***
  • Bual 54 (Henriques and Henriques) Burnt tobacco. Very savoury - I guess one might hope for a touch more mellowness in 10 years. Luxurious mouthwatering length. Delicious (and seems a tad better than my own bottles of this wine). ***(*)
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 05/01/2003   Return to top