Fine Wine Diary The Bailey brothers have now tasted 12016 wines in 21 years 11 months and 10 days
... search our archive of tasting notes ... read our articles on tastings and dinners

Diary index

Wine group at D.L.'s 28/11/2005 (TNB)

Montrose dinner 25/11/2005 (TNB)

The Diary - November 2005

Wine group at D.L.'s 28/11/2005 (TNB)

Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 30/12/2005   Return to top

Montrose dinner 25/11/2005 (TNB)

  • Chateau Montrose 1983 Lovely, classic Bordeaux nose. Bright fruit, but a very odd, harsh, late-palate and a slightly hot finish that leaves bitterness in the mouth. Would be lovely except for that. ***
  • Chateau Montrose 1981 Very nice - mineral, classic Claret. Lovely balance right through. For drinking. Top ***
  • Chateau Montrose 1975 Medium weight with a lovely savoury palate and a touch (not unpleasant now they are resolved) of the vintages tannins. I like this a lot - probably has more time left than the 81. Bare ****
  • Chateau Montrose 1971 Very nicely classic. Cigar box and sweet, ripe fruit nose. Follows through nicely with a high-toned palate. Bare ****
  • Chateau Montrose 1967 A bit faded, but alive and quite pleasant - splendid effort for the vintage. Very drinkable. From a half. Top **
  • Chateau Montrose 1970 Intriguing brown-sugar nose with lots of mineral terroir notes. Very classic and savoury - gorgeous. Returning to it: walnut nose and the palate too is like licking one. High-toned again. Really splendid but still needs time. *****(*)
  • Chateau Montrose 1966 Classic, quite austrere and high toned - very 66. Good length too, but it seems just very slightly corked. Clearly excellent, but I'll not rate it. Not Rated
  • Chateau Montrose 1964 (UK-bottled by Ellis) Stunning mix of flavours - quite fascinating. Hints at an edgy volatility too. Delicious but needs drinking - it may be a bit unstable. Top ****
  • Chateau Montrose 1962 Perfectly balanced mature Claret - So mineral. An absolute pleasure from beginning to end. *****
  • Chateau Montrose 1961 Stands out above the last two wines with an amazing extra depth and huge complexity. Suave, yet dry. Very, very long. No hurry to drink. ******
  • Chateau Montrose 1990 Very ripe and rounded - silky rich texture and a long, complex palate. Relatively forward. I can see how this got its rave reviews from Parker, but on returning there are piquant notes too. Top ****
  • Chateau Montrose 1989 Corked. Not Rated
  • Chateau Montrose 1988 Hopelessly oxidised - surely an odd bottle. Not Rated
  • Chateau Montrose 1986 Much more classic than the 90 - dry, flavoury with marked tannins. My impression is that while very good this won't become a star like the 70 or 61 - it seems a touch lighter. ***(*)
  • Chateau Montrose 1982 Exotic coconut nose, creamy. Not Claret as we know it, but fascinating. There's great depth and structure and so this probably will be stunning in a while. Bare ****(*)
  • Chateau Montrose 1999 Young wine cassis - but Montrose minerality too. Fairly ripe - it seems in a slightly softer more modern style than the later wines in this flight. Good though. *** (and improving)
  • Chateau Montrose 1998 Liquid minerals and excellent fruit. Very good and will be lovely. ***(*)
  • Chateau Montrose 1996 Very dense - a cross between 98 and 90. Qute a monster, but perhaps some of the older wines were that way in their youth. Still, this will surely be lovely in ten years. ***(**)
  • Chateau Montrose 1995 Mineral again but a bit more restrained and classic - less exotic than the 96. I like it a lot - almost more than the 96 - very stylish and balanced. ***(**)
  • Champagne "Un Jour de 1911" NV (A. Clouet) A blend of 91, 90 and 89. Apple and mushroom nose and palate - very meaty and substantial. Big finish. ****
  • Chateau Bouscaut blanc 1967 Two bottles, quite different. One very honied and becoming a bit austere. One fresher with nice richness. Both quite good. ***
  • Brauneberger Juffer Auslese 1975 (Konrad Prum) Pleasant old thing - it may be the end of a long night, but it seems just to be fading a touch. ***
Tasting notes added to Fine Wine Diary 26/12/2005   Return to top